A listener writes “I just recently listened to episode 916 ( butter street monster) due to me living down the road from that area since I was 13 years old. Now I’m 36 and I live in Germantown right off butter street, I take that road everyday to and from work. I transferred schools to Carlisle Ohio, in the 7th grade and lived off of Martz Paulin at the time of my sighting on morning star road.
I bring up my story because butter street and morning star are extremely close together and are surrounded by the same wooded areas and metro parks. Around 2008 I was driving down this road called Morning Star road in the middle of the night and witnessed what I can only imagine is Bigfoot related, or a guy in a very expensive Halloween costume. Background history of Morningstar road. Local town stories of people being killed at a camp site on the road in the 70’s, never really found any evidence about that part but there are some spooky spots on the road and some areas even now I would avoid at dark. Other stories from the road are an old house burnt down in the woods where the wife was running out in the middle of the road and was hit, or fell down the stairs and broke her neck(which ever side of the story is true I have no idea) ,which me and my friends were able to locate and find burnt remains of the forgotten house. Then the notorious Bigfoot sightings through out the years of this entire area. My stepmom was raised her whole life in Carlisle and recalls stories growing up of Bigfoot sightings along Morningstar road and twin creek(which bumps right up along the side of the road).
I recall my old English teacher who told me a story of her returning home from the store one night and seeming a creature which she claimed was easily 7-8 feet tall walking across the street from one wooded part to the other. Anyways fast forward to my experience. It was dark out and winter time. There was snow on the ground which the moon light up and made it easier to see the wood line on the road. There’s a few S type turns on Morningstar road that you have to really slow down on to maneuver safely on the road. Trees over lap these areas and make it really dark out at night with only your headlights guiding the way as any back country road is. While slowly going through one of the turns, there it was. Standing in between a tree or trees connected that formed a Y shape. It stood way taller than a normal size person and was covered in brown hair from head to toe from the angle we were seeing this at.
At this point we were going less than 5 miles per hour due to the roads being slick and the S turn. So the detail of what I seen was burnt into my memory. What ever it was squirted its eyes and covered its eyes with its hand to prevent from the lights blinding it I assume. First thing I noticed right away was when the light shine on its eyes, they were a yellowish color, almost as it had jaundice or something of the sort. The creature flash its teeth a little bit as it raises its freakishly big hand over its eyes blocking the light. The teeth didn’t seem to be in the best shape more browning yellow but bigger than normal human teeth. It turn its upper body and you can see the muscle definition in its back, tricep and lats before it turned the rest of its body and began walked down hill away from the vehicle. My friend began to freak out and scream while I began to yell just drive! My friend made it around the S type turn and floored it home. Which is only a min down the road. That image is forever remembered with clear detail .
I tell this story all the time and everyone of my friends laugh at me lol, but it doesn’t bug me. Me being a avid hunter , I think about this thing every time I step in the woods in the morning to hunt deer. It didn’t show any signs of aggression but still a sighting that spooked me. I always try to debunk everything that happens out of the ordinary , but this one has stumped me. Like I stated earlier, it could of been some one in a costume, but it would of had of been a very expensive costume which I doubt that had 16 years ago.”
David S
I live in Germantown. When we were kids there were always rumors of the “Butter Street Monster” which is not that far from the creepy Morningstar Road you are talking about…if it was a person in a suit on that road in the winter, they were an IDIOT. There was a young man in Germantown who was wearing a gorilla suit, pranking people….but who knows?
I am retired Army and Police and I do rucksack endurance matches in the Germantown Metro Parks and I am always alert to sounds and movement, but so far, normal wildlife encounters.. thanks for sharing.
Charles R
Thanks for your service on both accounts. I have never heard of a rucksack endurance match, however I bet it keeps you fit. Maybe some day you will have your encounter. These Metro Parks in the Greater Dayton area very good. Though this is not a Metro Park, the Sycamore State Park north of you and east of me was featured about 3 years ago, maybe more of twho high school age boys that were fishing the pond below the parking area shelter use area that stayed until dark. There had been a wedding reception in the shelter area that cleared out before they walked up the steep hill just as it got dark. To their amazement and being scared was a Bigfoot that was rumaging through the large trash container. They surprised the Bigfoot which then blasted towards the woods.
Charles R
Hi listener, it seems the Twin Creek avenue and area has been giving up Bigfoot encounters for some time. Adjacent Preble County where Twin Creek also flows through has 5 reports on the BFRO website, with most being in the Twin Creek area. July 30th of 2022 while motorcycling, I stopped at the bridge parking area on Enterprise Road as I do several time each year. This is on the NE side of Gratis, OH and the bridge crosses Twin Creek. I always walk the trail down to walk the banks looking for tracks. Coming back up after no success there is an enclosed fence area with maybe an old pumping station – not sure. I walk behind it where the trail which is hard packed grass and some gravel and there was one softer sandy spot. To my adulation there was one left foot track that I measured at 20.5 inches lenght X 10 inch width, plain as day. Jeepers, is this for real. I could see separation between the toes and all the little pebble gravel was pushed into the ground. I have pictures with my foot next to it on my phone. The next day I went back with my better camera and bought some casting material at Ace Hardware in Eaton. However it had rained some down there, July was a very wet month in 2022, and the track being very shallow it ruined it. The trail behind that fence is only 5 feet in width, then woods. I noticed the low vegetation at the wood line was disturbed also. I wondered if this was due to the right foot swinging out some as that track would be indictive of a Bigfoot close to the 10 foot height. I enjoyed hearing your sighting, I have never been on Morning Star Road, but have been down the 123 a good number of times. I live up outside of Arcanum and fish Twin Creek up here some and live in Twin Township where this creek starts. In the last couple of years, actually in winter of 2014 I first became aware of the Bigfoot activity that has occurred around Germantown, and certainly appreciate your experience. I also like those 2 ajoined UFOs houses there in Carlisle.
Ron S
I got as far as reading “”Morning Star” road, and I’m already smh. You don’t even need a decalcified pineal gland to read this street sign… But, I’ll read on now.
Ron S
Well, if you add together, “morning star” road, “S” turn, “twin” creek, the creature, the light blinding the creature etc. you get another instance of what I’ve been trying to explain… Wether it was a real creature or a person in a costume is IMO less important than the overall message (which is the same, if the sighting was real to the witness).
You still have to observe all the hallmarks and details as symbolism or metaphors in the situation. Some letters such as “S” relative to the encounter could be classified under a well known dark entity… not saying that (all S’s are bad) though. You have to contemplate, analyze in detail, and then shelf each bit of separate information captured in that one moment in time, to try and solve the riddle or at least get closer to the truth. Your experience is for yourself mainly, but it can help others in the honesty of it.
Personally, I think it’s kind of a shame that we have lost touch with our higher selves in many cases because it reveals so much truth and wisdom. At the same time this is still fairly new to me so I still see both sides of perception and how we got our senses so dulled.
Sometimes this truth I see all around us is so ugly and evil but still combined with so much beauty and love all at the same time. The contrast is so clear I can’t help but feel compelled to share my thoughts so we can all be in the light a little more. When you see more clearly the “real” reality can be so shocking, you might catch on quickly that the only balance, or only choice is 100% faith. I’ll try and explain…
In the encounter story above (like so many others) I see a perfect storm of events as evidence (with clues) and not coincidence… I really don’t know what coincidence means much anymore other than someone buying the same color car, or something like that, something that really doesn’t impact things very much.
This encounter speaks to me as a story of how God wants us to think in depth about things that trouble us, to seek and consult this divine wisdom for answers and in turn get to know Him, creation, ourselves and each other better.
The fact that we have failed him so much so far, that he had to allow evil on Earth so we’d form communities for all this unexplained strangeness seems pretty ridiculous, but in some cases it’s the best we have, and I’m grateful we have them. Sometimes we even let our own darkness into various communities or organizations and we mess up further as well, sometimes bickering with each other within these communities over silly prejudices… I’m sure I’ve probably been guilty of it myself, but I’m still learning too, just like anyone.
When you truly realize more of what life contains and what life is, you might suddenly stop thinking so much about yourself or your own desires, start to realize what you should be truly thankful for, humbled by, amazed by, fearful of or thinking about. Sometimes the process takes longer.
The power of Gods love, compassion and humility is evident in stories like this and even more evident in others. He isn’t going to brag (as there’s no sin in God or Heaven) so once again I’m going to fight again for his glory… I promised.
When reality hits you that God isn’t setting you up to have the tar flying out your rear or to ruin your life, you might just feel like someone actually did thump you over the head with a big ole heavy Bible. Here’s the shocker…It isn’t all about you… or me.
Let me ask a question…
Do you think the highest most powerful and supreme being allows evil on Earth because He likes to be mocked by it or see his creation destroyed or his children suffer? Of course not! We’re so quick to judge the One who says “do not judge”. But that’s the direction we’re kinda going, or being persuaded to go… The ole blame game.
I’d hate to see how much worse things are going to have to get with these unexplained things before it’s obvious. People getting snatched up or worse, with video proof? Makes a person wonder if we’d still figure it out… So much evil and violence already captured on video and people still doing the same stupid shtuff.
When you realize how Gods power works, it’s hard to wrap your mind around the controllability with simultaneous free will in accordance with His foresight, to allow evil to appear at such and such a place at such and a time and in such a way that everything according to the event is clues he wants you to discover for the betterment, wisdom and salvation of yourself now, and also in his Kingdom hopefully later, (where there is no pain or suffering or fear).
You might laugh as this. This only seems far fetched now because we’ve been slipping here for a while, which makes Heaven seem that much farther out of reach or harder to fathom… But it’s there… And I wish I could say it was for all, but the reality is, only for some… Breaks my heart.
I’ve not read much about purgatory, but I’m not convinced there is one solid answer. Only by taking a good guess I wouldn’t be surprised if it was something partially like this…
For non believers who are good, maybe there’s a place or a realm just like Earth, but unmolested… You are the only human soul, and you have to sit there by yourself in the nature of that world, where you truly have to contemplate and learn to fully appreciate things, including God and humanity (which you are currently lacking), for as long as it takes. Basically do what you failed to do here on Earth.
If you are bad but not entirely evil, maybe you go to the realm or place where the negative actions you caused in this lifetime are put back upon you. Like Earth but a crowded dirty place, everything broken or in ruins, accompanied by everyone you had an effect on, people who only contain the negative characteristics and emotions you unknowingly caused, the sadness or grief you put on others, which in turn helped create an existence of filth and chaos, where evil things have their way with you a lot more… Well, it could be worse. Better than nothing, at least you have an ounce of hope that it won’t last forever and you’re bound to get out sooner or later… And when you get out, maybe go sit in the other realm by yourself for a while, as long as it takes there as well. Idk, just a thought. Makes sense to me though that we should do what we can now, be good, thankful, get that contemplation out of the way so we can make quick work of an unnecessary stage and get right up to where we belong.
I know everyone doesn’t see things or experience things the way I do now and even I haven’t experienced things this way for most of my life… I guess the way I see it now is I have no choice but to try and wake people up… Even a few, and in turn if they could wake a few or inspire a few more positively in their own way… It keeps going and going more naturally, (better than the pink bunny) you know?
I hope so.